The Name of the Wind Review: Prose perfection, stilted story
It took me over half a year to read this book because it's so long and everyone in my town apparently wants to read it, so the hold time was ridiculous. I also got caught up in the drama that I'll never get to see the end of this story, so I was saddened and kept gravitating toward my other audiobooks, much to the chagrin of my dad and my cousin Andrew, to whom I dedicate this review to. Did this book live up to the hype of being one of the best fantasy novels of the generation? Is it so good that all the rioting about the third book is valid? That's what I, Brighton Nelson, will be discussing in today's review. Thanks for joining me, and I hope you enjoy your time on the site today!
Let's start with the negatives. I felt this book's conclusion left a lot to be desired. While it's understandable that it might be less conventional because of the book's inherent three-day structure, it didn't feel like Kvothe really went through a fun arc here, and it felt like it cut off sharply instead of tapering into a natural ending. It felt like there wasn't a climax, and while I'm not saying there should be world-ending stakes, the book felt less exciting in its third act, not more. I'm all for experimental climaxes and subverted storytelling structures. Still, this book eventually got to the point where it felt like a chore because Kvothe meandered through hundreds of pages with little internal or external purpose beyond "survive."
I never felt any narrative drive to keep going, and I often felt it was too slow-paced and slice-of-life to be the epic saga Kvothe was advertising. By the end, I felt the narrative itself was completely subpar externally. I only really cared about the internal stakes, romance, and unique dragon depiction for the last hundred-plus pages. I didn't want more action: I just wanted a reason to keep caring.
Other than the book's lack of intentional character-arc pacing, my only other criticism is that the magic and interludes are extremely underutilized. The rules of the magic are decently interesting, but the book explains them once early on. Then, there are only a couple of notable instances of the magic. I honestly forgot multiple times that he was going to school to be a magician. And the interludes? They never amounted to much. The idea was great, but... it never moved further from that.
Now for the positives. The worldbuilding, prose, character interactions, and lore were masterful. While the world isn't framed as grandiose because it's all through Kvothe's point of view, it feels so alive and sucks you in—especially if you listen via audiobook. This book has so many whimsical moments, even though Kvothe goes through hell and back for most of it. Whether approaching dragons in a fresh way, talking about the linguistics of foreign languages, rambling about philosophy, tackling poverty, or exploring the power of music, the book is always saying something important that fleshes out the world. The writing style here is so intentional and personal, and some of the most magical of any novel I've read. It feels like a true chronicle told in real time in a cavern. While I wish the novel had been more intentional in how it split the three days, the story feels so grandiose because it starts in his childhood.
The Brighton's Bookshelf Verdict
Brighton's Bookshelf Score: 7.5/10
Letter Score: C
While I had a lot of qualms with much of The Name of the Wind, it's told so beautifully and thoroughly with such intentional worldbuilding that I can look past my problems with the internal stakes, character arc, and magic system.
Interested in checking out some of my other book reviews? Check them out below!
Author Bio
Author Bio
Author Bio
Enjoy this review? Stay tuned for more articles from Brighton's Bookshelf! Enjoy video games, films, or music? Check out our sister sites, RPG Ranked & The Reel Ranker & Mr. Maestro, respectively!
